Devon TRF Group Forum

Members Login
Username 
 
Password 
    Remember Me  
Post Info TOPIC: New Car Reviews


Devon's Best

Status: Offline
Posts: 3263
Date:
New Car Reviews


After searching for a new car I have managed to get a shortlist, but stuck between a choice few, so any feedback would be appreciated.

Shortlist is - Passat CC, BMW 120D M Sport Coupe, BMW 320D Saloon, Mondeo TX Sport (200bhpwink) or Volvo V60 D2 R Design.

I have done over 270K over the last 6 yrs in Mondeo's and fancy a change, but the Mondeo comes out top in the reviews.

Does anyone have any of the above, and, if so, how do you rate it?

No rush as I have 3 weeks to get one......hmm



__________________

 

KTM Sunday = ATM Monday 

DTRF kd101146eb



Expert

Status: Offline
Posts: 1850
Date:

Merc vito sport 3 litre v6 240 hp , loadsa torque , bike fits in back,
Shames other " fast" cars at lights.
Comercial vehicle , so cheap tax + you can use loading bays

Bff

__________________

GG Red     4 strokes good, 2 strokes better

 

Complexity is the enemy of reliability

 



Devon's Best

Status: Offline
Posts: 3263
Date:

Biff wrote:

Merc vito sport 3 litre v6 240 hp , loadsa torque , bike fits in back,
Shames other " fast" cars at lights.
Comercial vehicle , so cheap tax + you can use loading bays

Bff


 Good call, but I do too many miles to have a van, and I have only just managed to get away from estate cars! (plus we have some Vito's I can borrow from work for bike transportwink)



__________________

 

KTM Sunday = ATM Monday 

DTRF kd101146eb



Expert

Status: Offline
Posts: 1990
Date:

I've been "thinking" about replacing my a4 - although I still love it to bits - and after a lot of thinking/reading I believe the newer BMW320D is a decent and efficient diesel engine. So my money would go there (and with my 35mile each way/day commute) I need something comfy, nippy and fuel efficient which can still handle well, looks good and brings a smile to my face. I'd get the tourer as shove the mx kit in the back when troys riding.

__________________

I feel the need..........

 

jt


Powermonger!!

Status: Offline
Posts: 8135
Date:

270K in 6 years = 43K a year ish?

 

I was doing almost that in a Hi Lux for 3 years mate no probs......get the van wink



__________________

'4 wheels move the body - 2 wheels move the soul'



Devon's Best

Status: Offline
Posts: 3263
Date:

jt wrote:
get the van wink

 Poor mpg in the vans, most new cars under 125g/km will give 50+mpg combined, and low taxwink



__________________

 

KTM Sunday = ATM Monday 

DTRF kd101146eb



Devon's Best

Status: Offline
Posts: 2961
Date:

Ford transit! epic, nicer to drive than a car by miles.

__________________

 



Expert

Status: Offline
Posts: 1229
Date:

Hate to say it but,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,it's the Volvo for me.smile



__________________
Chris
jt


Powermonger!!

Status: Offline
Posts: 8135
Date:

Oh Chris.......nodisbeliefhmm

 



__________________

'4 wheels move the body - 2 wheels move the soul'



Devon's Best

Status: Offline
Posts: 3263
Date:

chrisoncbr wrote:

Hate to say it but,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,it's the Volvo for me.smile


I do like the new V60, but am I allowed one at 32?

__________________

 

KTM Sunday = ATM Monday 

DTRF kd101146eb



Expert

Status: Offline
Posts: 1920
Date:

nickpdo wrote:
chrisoncbr wrote:

 

Hate to say it but,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,it's the Volvo for me.smile


 

I do like the new V60, but am I allowed one at 32?


  Get the volvo.

Youll be OK you look alot older 



__________________

CO2 more slippery than prison soap!

jt


Powermonger!!

Status: Offline
Posts: 8135
Date:

nickpdo wrote:

 

I do like the new V60, but am I allowed one at 32?


 No - cause the next thing will be that you forget the camper and get a bloody Caravan and stick behind it furious



__________________

'4 wheels move the body - 2 wheels move the soul'



Devon's Best

Status: Offline
Posts: 3263
Date:

jt wrote:
 No - cause the next thing will be that you forget the camper and get a bloody Caravan and stick behind it furious

 Yeah, about that.......

The wife makes a good case for a caravan, but I still have my dignity so the camper conversion is still on.wink



__________________

 

KTM Sunday = ATM Monday 

DTRF kd101146eb



Expert

Status: Offline
Posts: 1393
Date:

nickpdo wrote:
The wife makes a good case for a caravan

 

I don't know her but I'm sure that comment is quite harsh.  Just buy a GoldWing.



__________________

Make my day punk, CLICK on this....

FBF


Clubman A

Status: Offline
Posts: 804
Date:

Dunno if BMW have fixed it with the 320d but that had a major issue with exploding engine syndrome, problem with the intake swirl flap trashing the engine.

My ex wife bought one against my advise, told her to buy a VW or Skoda diesel but she a snob and badge orientated, 53k 2 years old and engine went bang 6 months after buying it. Didn't heed my advise but I'm a mechanic so wtf do I know?

Volvo should run for ever but later models are not like the old skool tanks and a little more flimsy than the old ones. Parts are horribly expensive at times but if you never need them then so waht? You will need a flat cap or deerstalker and may have to take up pipe smoking. Btw I have a really nice caravan for sale, no seriously I do!!

Passat. Its a Volkswagen, all you need to know. Make a nice taxi.

My advise, Go and buy a Skoda Superb



__________________


Devon's Best

Status: Offline
Posts: 3263
Date:

FBF wrote:
My advise, Go and buy a Skoda Superb

 Nice car but........., I really don't like the back endhmm Or the badgewink



__________________

 

KTM Sunday = ATM Monday 

DTRF kd101146eb

FBF


Clubman A

Status: Offline
Posts: 804
Date:

Granted, badge is like a winged penis and not desirable.

Would add had and still have a Skoda Fabia 1.4 petrol from new on a 04 plate and now has about 85k on it. Apart from a HT coil which misfired once and put the management light on and central door lock actuator that was sticky it had nothing under warranty. Both things were nitpicking tbh.

In that time its had wishbone bushes twice, last ones I stuck in were the solid A2 ones so thats fixed, brake discs front and rear, pads etc. Only thing wrong with it currently is the door sensor switch is buggered and doesn't turn the light on (common fault) and doesn't allow you to open the tailgate until you open another door, and thats it!! Still on same battery, exhaust, cambelt.



__________________
FBF


Clubman A

Status: Offline
Posts: 804
Date:

Btw if you like going to garages, buy a beemer wink



__________________


Devon's Best

Status: Offline
Posts: 3263
Date:

Cheers for the feedback, looks like one of these may be on the cards then. Better the devil you know........

 

http://www.autotrader.co.uk/classified/advert/201237484623842/sort/pricedesc/usedcars/engine-size-cars/2l_to_2-5l/maximum-mileage/up_to_10000_miles/transmission/manual/fuel-type/diesel/price-to/22500/maximum-age/up_to_1_year_old/body-type/hatchback/model/mondeo/make/ford/onesearchad/used/onesearchad/nearlynew/onesearchad/new/postcode/ta201bf/radius/1501/page/1/advert-type/standard-listing?logcode=ucnnp

Taking my colleagues 120D M sport out to play tomorrow night after the boat show to see if I like it.



__________________

 

KTM Sunday = ATM Monday 

DTRF kd101146eb

FBF


Clubman A

Status: Offline
Posts: 804
Date:

The Mondeo is a good car and the diesel high powered ones do shift somewhat. Reliable as well and will happily rack up the miles without complaint

Nothing is totally perfect though.

Don't see as many Mondeo's around like you used to either, probably because of the competition around that price range is fierce. They look quite tasty an all, not like the old shape bathtub with exploding bumpers if you dared to knock em.



__________________
FBF


Clubman A

Status: Offline
Posts: 804
Date:

Would add you will like the beemer, but they are hassle, unreliable and overated and desperately overpriced.

Had more than a few problem ones in the garage and basically wouldn't touch one. I hate working on my own cars which is why I have a Skoda as its relaible and well made and excellent value for money.



__________________
jt


Powermonger!!

Status: Offline
Posts: 8135
Date:

nickpdo wrote:

Taking my colleagues 120D M sport out to play tomorrow night after the boat show to see if I like it.


 Not a Beemer expert but have driven a 120 - you will love it, great to drive. Lot of wonga for a small car though hmm and there ain't much room. OK for you and Mrs PDO but IMHO it ain't a family car - if thats what you need.



__________________

'4 wheels move the body - 2 wheels move the soul'

jt


Powermonger!!

Status: Offline
Posts: 8135
Date:

FBF wrote:
I have a Skoda as its relaible and well made and excellent value for money.

 I love Skodas smile if i could afford a new Audi then I'd buy a Skoda cause it wasn't biggrin...........and then drive about feeling smug evertime I saw an Audi go past and think of all the money I saved......

 

My Grandad had one of these years back - I loved it smile

2871777799_1a2672fd47.jpg

 

An Estelle coupe - hell was it loud  ashamed wasn't fast as i recall - but sounded like it was doing 120 at about 40 wink



Attachments
__________________

'4 wheels move the body - 2 wheels move the soul'



Expert

Status: Offline
Posts: 1229
Date:

Not the Passat.  Too many arms on the front suspension and leccy handbrake.disbelief  Who needs that excreta......

 

And I know what you mean Jon, but they are well made, sorry.biggrin



__________________
Chris
jt


Powermonger!!

Status: Offline
Posts: 8135
Date:

Chap in work a few weeks back hired a (vectra I think) car which had leccy hand brake was driving down the A30 through Cornwall at 60-70 when the car suddenly skidded sideways as the back end locked up.

His missus was trying to lower the passenger window and flicked the leccy brake on by mistake.....

__________________

'4 wheels move the body - 2 wheels move the soul'



Expert

Status: Offline
Posts: 1161
Date:

nickpdo wrote:
chrisoncbr wrote:

 

Hate to say it but,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,it's the Volvo for me.smile


 

I do like the new V60, but am I allowed one at 32?


 

You obviously have not read the TRF membership terms & conditions Nick. Volvo drivers are disliked more than rambliars and caravaners! wink 



__________________

Adventure before dementia. KTM 500 exc >Devon TRF Member.     



Expert

Status: Offline
Posts: 1150
Date:

My Boss got a BMW 520d today, had a little play - LOVED it
ok it is new, and cost alot, but it is very comfy

__________________
Devon TRF - East Devon
jt


Powermonger!!

Status: Offline
Posts: 8135
Date:

I note the new volvo has a pedestrian air bag disbelief now the old duffers who drive them will think it will be fine to hit someone as they will be OK....

 

I think air bags part of the reason folk drive like compete diviots - 'I can crash as I'm gonna be fine and will be surrunded with big fluffy air bags' hmm If they replaced the air bag in the steering wheel with a 2 ft long spike that deployed in the event of a crash and went through the drivers head then we would have a lot of very careful drivers on the roads smile

 

Road safety according to JT biggrin



__________________

'4 wheels move the body - 2 wheels move the soul'



Expert

Status: Offline
Posts: 1229
Date:

I agree, JT.  It started with seat belts.  There's no need for the spike to deploy.  It needs to be there fixed & highly visible.biggrin  I think I saw you guys out yesterday at the crossroads on 7 mile straight.  I would have joined you but am off to France on my own Wednesday so thought I'd better spend some time with the better half.



__________________
Chris


Devon's Best

Status: Offline
Posts: 2961
Date:

jt wrote:

Chap in work a few weeks back hired a (vectra I think) car which had leccy hand brake was driving down the A30 through Cornwall at 60-70 when the car suddenly skidded sideways as the back end locked up.

His missus was trying to lower the passenger window and flicked the leccy brake on by mistake.....


 Did this when i had the discovery. my mate pulled it up when we were going along (for a laugh?) but nothing happened just a warning buzzer... Forgot about it until be dipped under 20mph and then crunch! stops dead! bleedy hell it was a shock for both of us more for him as he had taken off his seatbelt already no



__________________

 

jt


Powermonger!!

Status: Offline
Posts: 8135
Date:

chrisoncbr wrote:
  I think I saw you guys out yesterday at the crossroads on 7 mile straight.

 I twas us smile we had a cracking day....have fun in France mate!



__________________

'4 wheels move the body - 2 wheels move the soul'



Devon's Best

Status: Offline
Posts: 2421
Date:

Have to say I'd follow previous advice and get a Skoda Octavia Vrs - available as a petrol or diesel, the old Bill use 'em and they're way cheaper than equivalent German stuff.



__________________
Caution - the poster may well have been drinking........
jt


Powermonger!!

Status: Offline
Posts: 8135
Date:

Cracking cars smile my nephew (a copper) has the Fabia VRS and thats a belter as well....

 



__________________

'4 wheels move the body - 2 wheels move the soul'



Devon's Best

Status: Offline
Posts: 3263
Date:

Deposit paid, it'a blue and I collect on Wednesday.

But what did I go for?

__________________

 

KTM Sunday = ATM Monday 

DTRF kd101146eb

jt


Powermonger!!

Status: Offline
Posts: 8135
Date:

Something German I recon



__________________

'4 wheels move the body - 2 wheels move the soul'



Expert

Status: Offline
Posts: 1393
Date:

delvey91 wrote:

Ford transit! epic, nicer to drive than a car by miles.


 

Didn't I suggest one of those to you a while back?  You called me a pikey.... wink



__________________

Make my day punk, CLICK on this....



Devon's Best

Status: Offline
Posts: 3263
Date:

jt wrote:

Something German I recon


 Yep, and RWD.........



__________________

 

KTM Sunday = ATM Monday 

DTRF kd101146eb



Devon's Best

Status: Offline
Posts: 3263
Date:

Must say, very impressed by the new car (320D), much smoother drive than the Mondeo.

£20 a year road tax, and bloody quickwink

Tried the V60 R Design, nice but could only find a 1.6D.yawn



__________________

 

KTM Sunday = ATM Monday 

DTRF kd101146eb



Expert

Status: Offline
Posts: 1690
Date:

I've been following the thread I should imagine any of the above would suit you , we use skodas for RRVs at work I was shocked at the price of spares the resident mech asked on his update course how much is a diesel injector replacement , skoda told him you won't need one when pressed skoda said quot £1800 each ,in a lul at work again police say they love there five cylinder diesel BMW 320 very quick car but there now being replaced by skoda and Volvo ill have to have another chat with the patrol guys soon ?

__________________
Page 1 of 1  sorted by
 
Quick Reply

Please log in to post quick replies.



Create your own FREE Forum
Report Abuse
Powered by ActiveBoard